Sweet Potatoes vs Potatoes For Weight Loss

Listen to this article on Spotify, or watch it on YouTube.

Potatoes, a versatile staple, often spark questions when it comes to weight loss. Are they a friend or foe? Let’s delve into the world of potatoes and sweet potatoes to guide your weight loss diet.

Potatoes vs Sweet Potatoes

Potatoes hail from the starchy roots of Solanum tuberosum, and not all parts of the plant are safe for consumption. Avoid sprouted potatoes, especially if they turn green, as they may accumulate the toxin solanine. Luckily, sweet potatoes, from Ipomoea batatas, don’t share this concern, and their sprouts are safe to eat.

Potatoes Varieties

With over 200 types in the United States, potatoes offer diverse choices:

• Russet Potatoes: Ideal for baking, frying, and mashing.
• Red Potatoes: Perfect for boiling, roasting, or salads with a sweet and nutty flavor.
• White Potatoes: Great for boiling, roasting, or mashing, with a mild and slightly sweet taste.
• Yellow Potatoes: Suitable for boiling, roasting, or frying, boasting a sweet and buttery flavor.
• Blue/Purple Potatoes: High in antioxidants, with a nutty, earthy flavor.
• Fingerling Potatoes: Small, thin, and ideal for roasting or grilling.
• Petite Potatoes: Small, round, and versatile, perfect for various dishes.

While their nutritional values are similar, note that blue/purple potatoes offer more antioxidants, while fingerling potatoes have slightly higher calories and carbohydrates.

Sweet Potato Varieties

Sweet potatoes, not true potatoes, come in various types:

• Beauregard: Deep orange flesh, often used in pies and casseroles.
• Jewel: Deep orange flesh, ideal for sweet recipes like fries or roasted sweet potatoes.
• Garnet: Deep red skin, known for a sweeter taste, perfect for casseroles or mashed sweet potatoes.
• Hannah: Tan skin, less sweet, suitable for savory dishes like soups or stews.
• Japanese: Reddish-purple skin, used in Japanese cuisine like tempura or rice bowls.
• O’Henry: Light tan skin, slightly sweet, great for roasting or grilling.
• Purple: Deep purple skin, sweet and nutty, often used in vibrant pies or casseroles.

Each sweet potato type offers unique flavors and nutritional benefits, with varying concentrations of antioxidants.

Nutritional Benefits

The macronutrient densities of regular potatoes and sweet potatoes are also not that different.

Overall, both types are pretty comparable in terms of nutrition, and the exact amount of nutrition provided will depend on how they’re prepared.

For example baking or boiling for longer periods of time tend to increase the carbohydrate content for both.

Are Potatoes Bad for Weight Loss?

The notion that potatoes are an unhealthy choice for those looking to lose weight is unfounded. Research does not support the idea that potato consumption leads to weight gain or heart disease.

Surprisingly, studies indicate that adolescents who include potatoes in their diet may experience improved nutritional status, suggesting that potatoes can be a beneficial source of carbohydrates for this age group.

However, it’s important to note that negative health associations arise when dealing with fried potato products. For individuals with type 2 diabetes, there may be some considerations, given that potatoes are relatively high in carbohydrates. Monitoring carbohydrate intake is crucial in managing diabetes.

For those without diabetes, incorporating potatoes into your diet in a sensible manner—while avoiding fried versions—poses no significant risk of weight gain or heart disease.

Pros: Noteworthy Carb Benefits

While potatoes are rich in carbohydrates, primarily due to their starch content, they may not align with low-carb or ketogenic diets. Nonetheless, potatoes offer a substantial amount of fiber, especially when consumed with the skin.

In comparison to other commonly consumed carbohydrate sources, potatoes and sweet potatoes generally boast fewer calories and carbs per unit weight, while retaining a commendable amount of fiber. Additionally, potatoes are a rich source of essential vitamins and minerals, making them a more nutritious choice than alternatives like pasta or white bread.

Cons: Predominantly Carbohydrate Composition

Due to their predominantly carbohydrate nature, potatoes might not provide the same sense of fullness later in the day as foods higher in protein or fat, such as chicken or eggs.

For instance, a medium baked potato with gravy may not keep you feeling as satiated a few hours later compared to consuming three hard-boiled eggs, despite both providing approximately the same number of calories.

It’s worth noting that the carbohydrate in potatoes is not as complex as that found in nuts, seeds, beans, or lentils. Consequently, potatoes have a higher glycemic index, leading to a quicker increase in blood sugar levels. Nevertheless, their glycemic index is lower than that of highly refined carbs like muffins or breads.

Are Sweet Potatoes the Superior Choice?

In the realm of weight loss, sweet potatoes and regular potatoes yield practically identical effects. Both can be part of a healthy diet without one being significantly superior to the other.

Sweet potatoes have a natural sweetness, making them more likely to be enjoyed on their own, while regular potatoes often come with additions like butter or bacon.

However, piling condiments onto a regular potato can increase calorie intake and alter its nutritional profile, leading to a potential misconception that regular potatoes are less healthy.

But the belief that sweet potatoes are unequivocally superior is not entirely grounded in reality. Two prevalent myths need debunking:

MYTH 1: More Nutritious

The truth depends on the nutrients under consideration. Sweet potatoes excel in vitamin A (beta-carotene), vitamin C, and potassium, while regular potatoes boast more iron and magnesium. Both are nutritious, with slightly different nutrient concentrations.

No clear winner emerges in the nutrition department; they offer distinct benefits.

MYTH 2: Lower Glycemic Index

Once again, reality paints a different picture. While sweet potatoes may have slightly more soluble fiber, they contain more sugar, potentially increasing the glycemic index.

Preparation methods and the type of regular potato matter—Russet potatoes tend to have higher glycemic indexes than Red potatoes. In the end, fully baked sweet potatoes and regular potatoes often have similar glycemic indexes.

Summary

Potatoes and sweet potatoes are excellent sources of carbohydrates, providing a healthy alternative to pasta or rice in your meals. Whether you need a pre-workout energy boost or want to incorporate carbs into your diet, potatoes can be a delicious and nutritious choice.

For those craving something sweet while watching sugar intake, opting for a small sweet potato is a smart move.

To maximize the nutritional benefits while on a weight loss journey, it’s advisable to cook the whole potato, including the skin. This preserves essential nutrients that contribute to overall health.

However, not all potato products are created equal. Processed options like french fries or potato chips lack the wholesome advantages of whole potatoes. These processed variants are often high in calories, unhealthy fats, sodium, and undergo extensive processing, stripping away beneficial nutrients.

In your weight loss efforts, it’s wise to limit or avoid processed potato products. Opt for healthier alternatives like baked potatoes or sweet potatoes with minimal added fats and sodium. By making these mindful choices, you can enjoy the goodness of potatoes without compromising your weight loss goals.

See also

• 
  Doctor Reviews: Bee Bread
  Bee bread is fermented bee pollen, and may be quite nutritious, but lacks any researched health benefits in humans.
• 
  Arsenic in rice
  Rice often contains trace amounts of arsenic. White rice, and basmati rice from California, India, and Pakistan, tend to have lower amounts.
• 
  Mercury in fish and seafood
  Mercury is found in nearly all seafood, however tend to be in the highest concentrations in top-feeding, predatory fish, like shark and tuna.
• 
  Best Sugar Substitutes for Weight Loss
  Natural sweeteners may be better for health than artificial sweeteners, however using sugar substitutes does not support weight loss.
• 
  The Glycemic Index Diet: an overview
  The Glycemic Index diet focuses on foods that are lower in glycemic index and load, which can help with diabetes and weight loss.